Both omics reveal key roles for calcium transport, CA, and ECM synthesis.
Abstract
Ocean acidification (OA) and nanoplastics (NPs) increasingly co-occur in coastal ecosystems, yet their combined mechanistic impacts on calcifying invertebrates remain poorly resolved. Here, the mussel Mytilus coruscus was exposed for 30 days to factorial combinations of OA (pH 7.7 vs 8.1), surface-modified polystyrene NPs at a concentration of 100 μg/L (positively and negatively charged), and experimental shell damage to assess effects on shell repair, ion homeostasis, and energy metabolism. OA reduced shell repair quality by thinning repair layers, increasing porosity, and lowering calcium content, effects that were further enhanced by co-exposure to NPs, particularly negatively charged particles. OA and NPs jointly altered Ca2+ and Mg2+ levels, alkaline phosphatase activity, Ca2+Mg2+-ATPase activity, and key indicators of energy metabolism, including ATP content and cellular energy allocation. Transcriptomic and proteomic analyses revealed enrichment of ion transport, extracellular matrix, TGF-β signaling and other pathways, with divergent patterns linked to NPs surface charge. Together, these results suggest that nanoplastic surface charge under OA may impair mussel shell repair through associated alterations in ion homeostasis and energy metabolism. These findings highlight that particle surface properties shape how organisms respond to combined environmental stressors in acidifying marine environments.
CO₂-driven ocean acidification (OA) threatens marine calcifiers, while coastal ecosystems face increasing trace-metal contamination; their combined effects, and the modulating role of parental environmental history, remain poorly understood. We used the sea urchin Arbacia lixula from a naturally acidified CO₂ vent and a nearby ambient site at Ischia (Tyrrhenian Sea) to test how chronic adult exposure to low pH shapes larval responses to copper and low pH. Offspring from ambient (pH ~ 8.1) and vent (pH ~ 7.7) adults were reared for 48 h in a fully crossed design (two pH levels × three copper concentrations: 0, 5, 20 µg L⁻¹). At 24 hpf, development was dominated by parental history: ambient-derived larvae advanced rapidly, whereas vent-derived larvae showed higher arrest and slower progression, especially under low pH and high copper. By 48 hpf these effects diminished and pH and its interaction with copper became dominant, with both origins converging toward the echinopluteus stage. Nonetheless, malformations rose sharply under low pH regardless of copper, and skeletal-rod morphometrics revealed additional copper-related effects invisible to binary abnormality classifications. Chronic parental exposure did not enhance larval tolerance and sometimes increased sensitivity, underscoring the need to integrate multiple stressors and parental legacy.
Diatoms are a major phytoplankton group that plays a critical role in aquatic biogeochemical processes. Their metabolism relies on trace metals as cofactors for numerous enzymes, and changes in seawater pH may therefore influence metal sorption. Here, we investigated the effects of pH variability on diatom growth and trace-metal sorption using neutron activation analysis (NAA). Although NAA has rarely been applied to phytoplankton, we demonstrate its suitability for marine diatom samples. Overall, diatoms exposed to CO2 treatment exhibited higher cell abundance but lower intracellular elemental concentrations. In particular, Nitzschia navis-varingica showed significantly lower concentrations of Al, Ce, Co, Cr, Fe, Mg, Mn and Zn under the CO2 treatment. These trends are consistent with previous studies. For example, Zinc, which is a cofactor in many enzymes, plays a role in inorganic carbon acquisition; under lower pH, reduced enzymatic metal requirements likely explain the lower Zn concentrations observed. Nitzschia navis-varingica also had significantly lower levels of Co under lower pH. Both Thalassiosira pseudonana and Nitzschia navis-varingica showed lower Fe concentrations under CO2 treatment. As Iron is required for photosynthetic and respiratory processes that support the carbon-concentrating mechanism (CCM), reduced CCM activity at lower pH may decrease Fe demand. Overall, this study highlights NAA as a robust approach for quantifying metal sorption in marine organisms and provides new insight into the effects of ocean acidification on the growth and elemental composition of diatoms.
Phytoplankton are primary producers in marine ecosystems and play a central role in biogeochemical cycles, yet their physiological responses to altered seawater pH vary among taxa and over time. Here, we examined the effects of sustained pH manipulation on pigment composition, growth, and dark respiration in three ecologically important phytoplankton taxa – a diatom (Pseudo-nitzschia spp.), a dinoflagellate (Heterocapsa pygmaea), and a haptophyte (Emiliania huxleyi) – during a 15-day controlled laboratory experiment. Cultures were maintained at pH 8.1, 7.8, and 7.5, representing present-day and enhanced acidification conditions. Responses to pH were species-specific and strongly time-dependent. Growth and cell-specific respiration rates showed relatively small and often transient differences among pH treatments, suggesting short-term metabolic adjustment under altered pH. In contrast, pigment composition exhibited clearer and more consistent pH-related responses, primarily expressed as shifts in temporal patterns rather than uniform directional changes. In Pseudo-nitzschia spp. and H. pygmaea, several key pigments displayed pronounced pH-dependent trajectories, whereas E. huxleyi showed greater temporal variability and weaker separation among pH treatments. Overall, these results demonstrate that photophysiological traits respond sensitively to sustained pH changes even when population-level growth and respiration remain comparatively stable, highlighting pigment composition as a potentially sensitive indicator of short-term phytoplankton acclimation to ocean acidification.
Invasive macroalgae reduced P. oceanica seedling biomass and leaf development.
Macroalgal invasion depleted carbohydrate reserves in seedling roots and rhizomes.
Elevated CO2 increased rhizome starch but did not mitigate invasion impacts.
Root microbiome diversity declined markedly under macroalgal invasion.
Future CO2 enrichment unlikely to buffer invasion stress at recruitment stage.
Abstract
Seagrass seedlings are key to meadow recovery under global change, as they enable recolonization of degraded areas and provide genetic variability needed for adaptation. While invasive macroalgae increasingly threaten seagrass communities, elevated CO2 has been proposed to enhance seagrass performance and potentially buffer other stressors. Here, we conducted a mesocosm experiment to test the combined effects of two invasive macroalgae (Lophocladia trichoclados and Caulerpa cylindracea) and elevated CO2 on Posidonia oceanica seedlings. CO2 enrichment increased carbohydrate reserves in rhizomes and induced subtle shifts in root-associated microbiomes. In contrast, invasive macroalgae had consistently negative effects on seedling development and physiology and strongly altered both above- and belowground microbial communities. Despite its potential to stimulate seagrass productivity, elevated CO2 did not mitigate the detrimental impacts of invasive macroalgae. These findings indicate that future CO2 conditions may not offset invasion-driven stress at the recruitment stage, highlighting the need for targeted management efforts to limit macroalgal proliferation and support seagrass meadow regeneration.
Low salinity linked to warming may intensify coastal pH reduction.
Low salinity reduced righting and emergence in the limpet Patelloida pygmaea.
Low salinity reduces Mg/Ca ratios in newly formed shell layers.
Low pH increases shell thickness and Mg/Ca ratios despite dissolution.
CHS2 upregulation suggests compensatory resistance to low pH.
Abstract
Rising anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions have driven ongoing ocean warming and associated climate changes. In the Yellow Sea, this warming is associated with enhanced monsoonal rainfall, which increases freshwater inputs and lowers coastal salinity. Increased freshwater input can weaken seawater buffering capacity, thereby leading to lower pH conditions in coastal environments. Here, we examined the effects of low pH and low salinity on the intertidal limpet Patelloida pygmaea. Adult limpets were exposed for 31 days to four experimental artificial seawater conditions combining two pH levels (8.0 and 7.5) and two salinity levels (30 and 21 psu). Survival and condition factor were not influenced by pH or salinity. However, low salinity reduced righting and emergence behavior. In addition, the Mg/Ca ratio in the M + 1 layer was lower at 21 psu than at 30 psu. Low pH resulted in a thicker M + 2 layer with higher Mg/Ca ratios despite shell dissolution, potentially helping to maintain shell integrity. While there was no change in heat shock protein (HSP70) expression, these shell modifications were accompanied by an upregulation of chitin synthase (CHS2) genes under low pH. These findings suggest that P. pygmaea is negatively influenced by low pH and low salinity, but also demonstrate compensatory mechanisms that enhance resistance to low pH.
The present study experimentally investigates how temperature and acidification affect the polar lipid fatty acid (FA) composition of European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) juveniles. Fish were reared for 92 days and fed ad libitum under four conditions: a control (CT; with natural fluctuating temperature and pH); a warming (WT, +4°C above control, and control pH), an acidification (AT, control temperature and −0.4 pH units below the control), and a combined warming and acidification treatment (WAT, +4°C and −0.4 pH units relative to the control). Results showed that warm treatments (WT and WAT) increased final weight and length similarly, whether or not combined with acidification, and that acidification alone (AT) had no effect on these variables. Polar lipid FA profiles of muscle and brain were only mildly impacted by temperature and not by acidification. Overall, the results suggest that European sea bass, under unrestricted quantity of food is able to maintain a very stable polar lipid FA composition. However, complementary studies with individuals under different feeding regimes or from wild populations subject to natural dietary variability are needed.
Nutrient limits the phytoplankton growth in the Bay of Bengal due to stratification.
Picoplankton dominated the phytoplankton community in the Bay.
An increase in phytoplankton biomass was observed in response to ocean acidification (OA) in nutrient-rich regions.
Decrease in phytoplankton biomass, bacteria and microzooplankton abundance was found in the nutrient-poor regions.
Nutrient limitation overshadow the ocean acidification impact in the Bay of Bengal.
Abstract
The perennial rise in atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) from anthropogenic activities increased oceanic carbon uptake, thereby lowering seawater pH. Rapid ocean acidification (OA) by 2 to 3 times than other regions of the same latitudinal belts was reported in the Bay of Bengal (BoB) due to the deposition of atmospheric pollutants, in addition to the dissolution of atmospheric CO2. Therefore, the impact of OA on phytoplankton composition is hypothesized to be greater in the BoB than elsewhere in the globe. On the other hand, the BoB experiences intense oligotrophic conditions due to strong stratification driven by nutrient-poor freshwater discharge from major rivers, which is the primary bottleneck for phytoplankton growth, rather than carbon. It is hypothesized that nutrient limitation may overshadow OA’s impact on plankton in the BoB. To test this hypothesis, six microcosm experiments were conducted in the western BoB between 13 and 20°N with different nutrient levels in the surface waters. The pH of the surface water was adjusted by 0.2 units below the ambient pH using CO2 gas bubbling to simulate the projected OA scenario for the year 2100. Following pH adjustment, incubations were carried out for three days. Picoplankton dominated the phytoplankton community (∼96%) at all stations, with prochlorophytes as the dominant group. Among the phytoplankton, procholorophytes, diatoms, and prymeniophytes increased due to OA across all stations, while other groups of phytoplankton were declined. The increase in phytoplankton biomass was observed in the nutrient-rich stations, while a decrease in phytoplankton biomass, bacteria and microzooplankton abundance was found in the nutrient-poor stations, suggesting that nutrient availability dominated over the OA. Under a business-as-usual scenario, an increase in stratification due to melting Himalayan glaciers is projected, leading to strong stratification and reduced nutrient inputs through vertical mixing in the future in the BoB. Under such a scenario, nutrient limitation may possibly overshadow the OA impact in the future, despite a rapid decline in pH driven by increased CO2 dissolution and deposition of atmospheric pollutants.
High carbonate alkalinity can impose composite hydrochemical stress on bivalves by altering inorganic carbon speciation, buffering capacity and ion-exchange conditions. The Hong Kong oyster (Crassostrea hongkongensis) naturally inhabits estuarine areas where low salinity can occur together with carbonate-system disturbance, yet its physiological response to high carbonate alkalinity under a low-salinity background remains unclear. In this study, oysters were exposed at salinity 5 to a Control treatment, A10 (carbonate alkalinity 10 mmol L⁻¹) and A20 (carbonate alkalinity 20 mmol L⁻¹). Salinity was treated as a controlled background condition, whereas the alkalinity treatments represented a composite carbonate-alkalinity perturbation involving alkalinity, pH and carbonate chemistry. Survival, feeding rate, oxygen consumption, ammonia excretion and hemolymph ammonia were measured across Control, A10 and A20. Hemolymph catalase (CAT), glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px), glucose and ATP were analyzed as A10 and A20 time-course endpoints because a parallel Control was not included for these assays. A 24-h mantle transcriptome was used to screen candidate transcripts associated with innate defense and glutathione metabolism. Oysters under A10 retained partial compensatory capacity, whereas A20 significantly reduced survival. A10 and A20 suppressed early oxygen consumption and ammonia excretion, and altered feeding allocation among microalgae. Within the A10 and A20 biochemical time-course dataset, CAT, GSH-Px, glucose and ATP showed stage-specific variation, suggesting redox and energy-metabolism adjustment under alkalinity stress. Overall, high carbonate alkalinity reduced survival and was associated with metabolic depression, feeding compensation and hemolymph redox-energy remodeling in C. hongkongensis. This study will provide a theoretical basis for water quality regulation in saline-alkaline water aquaculture and the sustainable development of aquaculture.
Remote sensing indicates declining bloom in cold and developing bloom in warm water
Primary production peaks in polar and arctic surface water masses
Bacterial production is coupled to primary production despite thermal sensitivity
Oxygen-based community respiration is highest in warmer water masses
Oxygen-based and INT-based respiration estimates differ by an order of magnitude
Abstract
The Fram Strait is the primary oceanic gateway to the Arctic Ocean and has highly dynamic oceanographic conditions. Oceanographic conditions can shape community compositions, which is increasingly shown using molecular studies, but rate measurements remain scarce, especially for respiration in the Arctic Ocean. Here, we assessed primary production (PP), bacterial production (BP), bacterial abundances (BA), and community respiration (CR) using Winkler titrations and in vivo Iodo-Nitro-Tetrazolium (INT) reduction within the upper 50 m across water masses of the Fram Strait that had varying bloom conditions in spring 2021. We complemented in situ observations with remote sensing of sea surface temperature (SST) and chlorophyll-a (SSC) to infer bloom phenology in warm (θ>2°C), intermediate (2>θ>0°C), and cold (θ<0°C) waters using remote sensing machine-learning. In the cold, nutrient-rich surface waters, a subsiding spring bloom was associated with elevated PP, BP, and BA alongside a high temperature sensitivity (Q10) that indicates active microbial turnover. In contrast, the warm Atlantic-influenced waters exhibit a relatively lower PP but moderate cell-specific BP, suggesting bacterial maintenance metabolism under pre-bloom conditions. Notably, bacterial respiration (BR) estimates differed by 5- to 80-fold between the Winkler and in vivo INT methods. Although the true BR likely lies between these estimates, our results highlight the substantial microbial activity and underscore the need for more accurate BR measurements in Arctic studies.
Mixotrophic protists capable of both photosynthesis and phagotrophy are key members of marine plankton communities. Yet, little is known about their responses to the combination of ocean acidification and warming.
A marine mixotrophic chrysophyte, Ochromonas CCMP2951, was subjected to two levels of pCO2 (300 and 800 ppm, resulting in pH of 8.2 and 7.8) and temperature (21°C and 26°C) in a factorial design.
Enhanced growth rates were observed in both the high CO2 and high temperature treatments, while cell size significantly decreased with temperature. Strongly decreased cellular phosphorus content led to increased N : P and C : P ratios of Ochromonas with temperature. Furthermore, warming increased grazing rates, while elevated CO2 reduced the Chl content but increased photosynthetic carbon acquisition, albeit only at low temperature. The combination of warming and elevated CO2 had antagonistic effects on the balance between autotrophic and heterotrophic carbon acquisition, keeping the net role of this mixotroph in the marine carbon cycle stable.
Altogether, both the direct stimulation of growth and the indirect effects of altered stoichiometry may favor mixotrophs under future ocean conditions. However, their contribution to future carbon cycling in complex natural communities will need further study.
Graphical Abstract
Grazing rates of Ochromonas CCMP2951 expressed as carbon obtained per mean cell volume (a) and Caut/het-photosynthetically fixed carbon divided by carbon obtained through grazing (b) in the four experimental treatments.
Low pH conditions at CO₂ vents increase THg bioavailability and fish exposure.
Functional traits explain THg patterns better than species identity.
Under low pH, less-mobile benthic fish accumulate more THg than highly-mobile fish.
Trophic position drives stronger THg biomagnification at low pH sites.
Abstract
Ocean acidification is not an isolated climate-related threat to marine organisms, as it may act in combination with other stressors such as trace element contamination. Here, we took advantage of naturally acidified conditions and mercury spill-out from the shallow CO2 vent of Vulcano Island (Italy) to test whether fish functional traits explain contaminant dynamics better than species identity under ocean acidification scenarios. Specifically, we investigated if trophic group and mobility influence total mercury (THg) bioaccumulation and trophic transfer in fish inhabiting Cymodocea nodosa seagrass meadows under low and ambient pH conditions. Low-mobility benthic fish, mainly represented by invertebrate feeders and small piscivores, exhibited higher THg concentration at the vent site than at reference sites, while highly mobile zooplanktivorous fish showed no significant differences, highlighting the importance of fish mobility and local trophic benthic pathways in shaping contaminant exposure and bioaccumulation. Moreover, the relationship between trophic position and THg concentration in fish was stronger in the low pH site, indicating enhanced trophic transfer and biomagnification when Hg availability is higher. In contrast, weak or absent biomagnification in the reference sites suggests that Hg transfer depends more on contaminant availability and food web structure than trophic position alone. Overall, these findings indicate that functional traits better predict Hg bioaccumulation patterns than species identity, supporting trait-based approach to assess contaminant dynamics in future ocean acidification scenarios.
Anthropogenic CO2 emissions are altering marine ecosystems through two interconnected processes: climate change and ocean acidification, both of which are particularly affecting the Southern Ocean. However, the molecular responses of cold-water corals to these stressors remain poorly understood. In this study, we investigated the transcriptomic response of the Antarctic coral Malacobelemnon daytoni exposed to ocean acidification (pH ~7.7; LpH) and elevated temperatures (+2°C and +4°C above ambient; T1 and T2, respectively) under controlled laboratory conditions. Using high-throughput RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq), we compared gene expression profiles across six treatments, including a control (pH ~8.1, CpH; 0–1°C; CT), acidification, warming, and their combinations. Principal component analysis revealed treatment-specific clustering and greater transcriptomic dispersion under LpH conditions. Differential expression analysis identified between 475 and 767 differentially expressed genes (DEGs), with the strongest transcriptional responses observed under combined stress conditions (LpH + T1 and LpH + T2). Combined exposure to ocean acidification and warming elicited the largest gene expression response, suggesting enhanced, potentially non-additive effects of multiple stressors. Functional enrichment analyses revealed differential regulation of genes associated with protein folding, signal transduction, energy metabolism, oxidative stress, and regulation of cell death. Our findings demonstrate that Malacobelemnon daytoni exhibits complex, treatment-dependent gene expression responses to environmental stressors. These results highlight the capacity of this Antarctic octocoral to mount molecular responses to projected future ocean conditions while also emphasizing its potential vulnerability to the interacting effects of ocean warming and acidification.
Climate change models predict future ocean-wide decreases in pH and increases in temperature, posing a serious threat to calcifying marine invertebrates. In Hawaiʻi, local seawater temperature and pH are predicted to change even more rapidly. The Hawaiian oyster Dendostrea sandvichensis, an endemic species, remains understudied despite its ecological roles in reef- building, biofiltration, and as a food source. While previous studies have revealed the alarming impacts of ocean acidification and warming on bivalves, little is known about how the planktonic larvae of D. sandvichensis will respond to projected climate conditions.
To investigate these effects, the larvae of D. Sandvichensis were reared under present-day conditions in Pearl Harbor, HI (pH 8.1, 26.5 °C) and projected future conditions (pH 7.7, 30.0°C) for one week. Shell growth, density, and degradation were then measured using micro-CT, confocal, and scanning electron microscopy. Additionally, two larval husbandry methods were evaluated, with a static-flow system paired with UV water treatment yielding approximately 11- fold higher survival than an open-flow system. Elevated temperature reduced larval survival (~67%) compared to ambient conditions. Reduced pH significantly decreased shell length (~11.8μm), while both stressors reduced shell density in Experiment 3. Shell density decreased by ~12% under elevated temperature, ~18% under reduced pH, and ~43% under the combined stressors, and was accompanied by increased shell degradation and abnormalities.
These findings indicate that elevated temperature and reduced pH impact larval oysters through multiple pathways, including reduced survival and compromised shell integrity. This study provides new insights into the vulnerability of an endemic Hawaiian species and essential data for predicting its resilience under future climate change scenarios.
Climate change explains ∼40% of biological stress variance in Mediterranean mussels.
Ocean acidification drives 67% of metal bioavailability changes via pH-metal speciation.
64% of climate effects on biomarkers operate indirectly through metal bioaccumulation.
Multi-method convergence (LMG, GAM, SEM, Bayesian Networks) confirms stressor ranking.
Only SSP1-2.6 keeps biological stress below the chronic-stress threshold through 2050.
Abstract
Marine coastal ecosystems face concurrent pressure from climate change and anthropogenic contamination, yet their relative contributions to biological stress remain poorly quantified. Here we present a decade-long (2014–2023) biomonitoring study on Mytilus galloprovincialis in the Ligurian Sea (NW Mediterranean), integrating quarterly biomarker measurements, heavy metal bioaccumulation data (12 metals), and high-resolution oceanographic records at a control site (Gorgona Island Marine Protected Area) and an offshore regasification terminal.
Biological stress variance was partitioned using five complementary analytical frameworks — Lindeman–Merenda–Gold (LMG) variance decomposition, Hierarchical and Generalised Additive Models (HGAM/GAM), Structural Equation Modelling (SEM), and Bayesian Networks — applied to four biomarkers: DNA damage, lysosomal membrane stability, gill tissue integrity, and immune response. A campaign-specific T0 baseline normalisation isolated environmental signals from initial population variability.
Climate change emerged as the dominant driver, consistently explaining ∼40% of variance across all methods, significantly exceeding metal bioaccumulation (∼30%), terminal influence (∼13%), and seasonal effects (∼2%). Ocean acidification was the primary climate mechanism, influencing 67% of analysed metals. Causal mediation analysis revealed that 64% of the climate effect operates indirectly through enhanced metal bioaccumulation (Climate→Metals→Biomarkers), while 36% acts directly. Climate and biological stress indices co-varied strongly (ρ = 0.78, p < 0.001), with marine heatwaves coinciding with peak biomarker responses.
Under IPCC Shared Socioeconomic Pathway (SSP) scenarios, the Biological Stress Index is projected to cross chronic-stress thresholds by 2035–2040 under the high-emission scenario (SSP5-8.5) and the intermediate-emission scenario (SSP2-4.5), with only the low-emission scenario (SSP1-2.6) maintaining stress below critical levels through 2050.
These findings challenge pollution-centric monitoring paradigms and demonstrate that CO2 mitigation now constitutes the highest-leverage intervention for marine invertebrate health in the Mediterranean.
Graphical abstract
This graphical abstract illustrates the main findings of a decade-long field study (2014–2023) on the effects of climate change and metal contamination on Mytilus galloprovincialis in the Ligurian Sea (NW Mediterranean). Three panels summarise the causal chain from environmental drivers to biological outcomes. The first panel depicts the key oceanographic trends recorded at the study site: ocean warming (+0.41°C/decade), acidification (−0.020 pH units/decade), deoxygenation, and a doubling of marine heatwave frequency after 2018. The second panel shows how pH decline enhances the bioavailability of 67% of the metals analysed, driving a predominantly indirect pathway (64%) from climate stressors to biological stress, mediated by metal bioaccumulation, as revealed by structural equation modelling and Bayesian network analysis. The final panel presents the four biomarkers used to compute the Biological Stress Index (BSI), its strong temporal correlation with the Climate Change Index (ρ = 0.78), and BSI projections to 2050 under three IPCC emission scenarios, showing that only SSP1-2.6 keeps BSI below the chronic-stress threshold throughout the projection period.
Seagrasses provide valuable ecosystem functions, yet they are declining globally due to anthropogenic stressors. Understanding how global climate stressors like ocean acidification interact with local environmental conditions (e.g., increased nutrient pollution) to affect ecosystem dynamics can be used to inform management of these habitats. In San Francisco Bay, it is unknown how stressor interactions will affect herbivory by Ampithoe valida, an invasive amphipod that exhibits novel feeding behavior by directly consuming the tissue of Zostera marina (eelgrass), which has been linked to negative impacts on local meadows. The goal of this study was to determine how anthropogenic stressors and amphipod size influence A. valida herbivory on eelgrass in San Francisco Bay to evaluate the ecological implications for eelgrass habitats. To further understand this relationship, feeding assays first examined food preferences of A. valida of three sizes on eelgrass of two ages and epiphytic algae. Secondly, a mesocosm experiment exposed A. valida of medium and large sizes to levels of ocean acidification expected with accelerating climate change and eelgrass to levels of nutrient pollution possible from point sources along shorelines, to test if these combined stressors affect A. valida direct herbivory of eelgrass. Additionally, A. valida were collected in the field during peak eelgrass growing season in summer and early fall to determine their size distributions and provide context to the experiments. Results found that A. valida largely prefer epiphytic algae over eelgrass regardless of their size. When offered only eelgrass, medium to large individuals consumed the tissue, whereas small individuals exhibited near-zero consumption. Although small A. valida were most abundant in field collections, medium-sized individuals were also present in moderate numbers, suggesting amphipods of this size may be the primary contributors to direct eelgrass consumption in San Francisco Bay, with high-consuming large individuals less common. Mesocosm results indicated that increased nutrients reduced eelgrass aboveground morphology (leaf size) and biomass, while tissue nutrient content increased, suggesting that although nutrients were taken up, they were not used for growth. Finally, feeding assays revealed that the effects of reduced pH and nutrient additions on A. valida eelgrass herbivory varied with grazer size and experimental context. In the no-choice assay, medium-sized individuals increased consumption under reduced pH relative to ambient pH, while large individuals consumed more of the highest nutrient-enriched eelgrass tissue. In contrast, the choice assay showed higher eelgrass consumption under ambient pH relative to reduced pH, and no effect of nutrient additions. This suggests that under reduced pH A. valida may shift their feeding behavior depending on environmental context, potentially increasing consumption through compensatory feeding on lower-quality tissue when food options are limited or reducing consumption when alternative refugia and higher-quality resources are available. This also indicates that ocean acidification may primarily alter eelgrass grazing behavior among mid sized A. valida, while nutrient enrichment may increase grazing pressure from larger individuals, potentially exacerbating eelgrass vulnerability in San Francisco Bay given reduced plant performance under high-nutrient conditions.
Alexandrium blooms occurred with normoxic conditions and moderate pH (7.5-8.0).
Alexandrium blooms occurred with moderate pCO2 (400 – 1,000 µatm) and saturating conditions for aragonite.
Dinophysis blooms co-occurred nocturnal acidification (8.71 to 13.6 hr d−1) and hypoxia (0.52 to 3.88 hr d−1).
Dinophysis blooms co-occurred with high pCO2 (1,000 – 3,500 µatm) and undersaturated aragonite (Ωar < 1).
The co-occurrence of nocturnal hypoxia, acidification, Ωar undersaturation, and HABs coupled is a significant threat for marine life.
Abstract
While harmful algal blooms (HABs), hypoxia, and ocean acidification are common occurrences in coastal zones, research investigating the co-occurrence and interactions between these processes has been lacking. Here, we documented the initiation, peak, and demise of eight distinct HAB events caused by Alexandrium catenella and Dinophysis acuminata over a two-year period in two estuaries (Northport Harbor and Cold Spring Harbor, NY, USA). We concurrently characterized the dynamics of carbonate chemistry, including pCO2 and the saturation state of aragonite (Ωar), pH, dissolved oxygen (DO), and general environmental conditions in space and time. HABs occurred in succession and reached high densities with A. catenella blooms exceeding 104 cells L−1 being succeeded by D. acuminata blooms exceeding 106 cells L−1. A. catenella blooms occurred during spring months under generally normoxic conditions with moderate levels of pCO2 (400 – 1,000 µatm), only brief periods of acidification (pH < 7.5), mostly saturating conditions for aragonite, and an absence of hypoxia. In contrast, D. acuminata blooms, which occurred in summer, consistently co-occurred with bouts of extended nocturnal acidification (8.71 to 13.6 hr d−1) and hypoxia (0.52 to 3.88 hr d−1) coupled with higher levels of pCO2 (1,000 – 3,500 µatm), and undersaturating conditions for aragonite (Ωar < 1). During both blooms, nearshore locations hosted higher cell densities, lower pH and DO, and higher pCO2 compared to open water regions. The co-occurrence of multiple stressors including nocturnal hypoxia, acidification, Ωar undersaturation, and HABs, coupled with strong diel cycling of DO, pH, and pCO2, especially during D. acuminata blooms, represents a significant and previously unrecognized threat for marine life.
Absorption of CO2 by global oceans is decreasing pH resulting in ocean acidification (OA). Impacts on shellfish have been documented in ecologically and commercially important species. We examined the influence of diet and OA between two populations of red abalone (Haliotis rufescens) a species of aquaculture importance and declining wild populations. Populations experience different exposure histories: strong upwelling (Van Damme, California [VD]) historically exposed to low-pH conditions and weak-intermittent upwelling (Santa Barbara, California [SB]). Abalone were cultured under control-pH or OA-conditions and fed crustose coralline algae (CCA) or diatoms used in aquaculture. We tested treatment effects of population, settlement diet, and OA-exposure on survival as influenced by larval-energy stores. Survival in both populations was enhanced by CCA when cultured under both treatment conditions; however, by later stages, this effect remained only for SB. SB had reduced post-settlement survival when cultured under OA-conditions, whereas post-settlement survival of VD was not. Diet affected the relationship between larval-energy and post-settlement survival; a positive relationship when fed diatoms and a negative relationship with CCA. The relationship between larval energy and post-settlement survival was stronger in VD. CCA enhanced juvenile growth in SB cultured abalone at both three-months and one-year post-settlement. Settlement diets can reduce the impacts of OA on early-life stages of abalone, but population differences driven by underlying energetics affect the consistency of this outcome. These findings illuminate the impacts from OA, suggesting populations may be at risk, and inform strategies for developing and sustaining shellfish aquaculture in the face of changing ocean conditions.
To investigate the effects of ocean acidification (OA) on macroalgae, we conducted in situ surveys along a natural CO2 vent gradient in Shikine Island, Japan, together with complementary laboratory culture experiments. The in-situ surveys revealed that near the CO2 vent (where pH dropped by 0.37), macroalgal diversity and species-richness were less than half those at the reference sites under ambient pH conditions. Nevertheless, the rates of CO2 assimilation of several common macroalgae increased from the reference site to the areas near the CO2 vent. This enhancement coincided with decreased photosynthetic CO2 affinity, reflecting that the acidified area down-regulated CO2-concentrating mechanisms in the algae. Measured photosystem II activity revealed that macroalgae at reference sites had lower electron transport rate and light utilization efficiency. The laboratory culture experiments, in which the dominant species (Gelidium elegans and Dictyopteris undulata), were cross-exposed to ambient and elevated CO2 conditions, further demonstrated that the stress near the CO2 vent significantly exacerbated photoinhibition under high light stress. Our results demonstrate that reduced pH and high sunlight act synergistically to impair macroalgal photosynthesis through exacerbated photoinhibition. This effect was more pronounced in red algae (e.g., G. elegans) than in brown algae (e.g., D. undulata). These different physiological responses provide a mechanistic explanation for an observed community shift, from red algal dominance in ambient pCO2 areas to brown algal dominance near the vent. Our findings imply that future OA, when combined with high-light stress, may selectively disadvantage high-light-sensitive species, thereby altering macroalgal community structure in coastal waters.
This study evaluated how the combination of ocean warming, acidification, and deoxygenation (“deadly trio”) affects the early development of the fish Sparus aurata. Embryos and recently hatched larvae were exposed to increased temperature (Δ + 4 °C; 22 °C), elevated CO2 levels (pCO2 ~1000 μatm, Δ − 0.4 units; pH 7.7), and reduced oxygen (Δ − 60% O2 saturation; 3 mg O2 L −1). Deoxygenation emerged as the primary stressor, significantly reducing hatching rates, larval survival, and heart rates. These effects were further intensified when combined with warming and acidification. Acidification alone also reduced larval phototactic behavior by 50%, while exposure to all three stressors eliminated phototactic responses entirely. Overall, the results demonstrate that multiple climate-related stressors together severely harm fish early life stages, emphasizing the need to study combined environmental changes to better predict future impacts of climate change on marine fish populations and ecosystem functioning.
Abstract
The interaction between increased dissolved carbon dioxide, rising temperatures, and oxygen loss—the so-called “deadly trio”—is expected to strongly affect marine biota over the coming years, undermining ocean services and uses. Nonetheless, no study has so far scrutinized the cumulative impact of these three stressors on fish embryos and larvae. To fill this knowledge gap, we conducted a fully multi-factorial experiment to investigate the effects of warming (+4 °C: 22 °C), acidification (Δ − 0.4 pH units: 7.7 pH, pCO2 ~1000 μatm), and deoxygenation (Δ − 60% O2 saturation: 3 mg O2 L−1) on physiological and behavioral responses of the commercially important species Sparus aurata. Deoxygenation was the primary factor reducing hatching rates (64.25%), survival (46.71%), and heart rates (31.99%) of recently hatched larvae, being generally further exacerbated when combined with warming and acidification. No larvae exposed to the interaction of the three treatments reacted to the phototactic behavior test. However, acidification alone caused a 50% reduction in phototactic behavior. Our findings demonstrate that the deadly trio is detrimental to early fish development, impacting several key features at this critical life stage, and the need to assess the impacts of stressors’ interaction on marine taxa to better predict future ecosystem responses to ocean changes.
