Global climate change is exacerbating multiple ocean stressors, including ocean acidification (OA), ocean warming (OW), and deoxygenation (deOxy), which collectively threaten marine ecosystems and fisheries. Understanding how these stressors interact to shape organismal and ecosystem responses is increasingly critical, yet it remains technically challenging and expensive to simulate them concurrently under controlled indoor conditions. To address this limitation, we developed a closed indoor mesocosm system that enables stable and long-term simulation of these three stressors for biological and aquaculture research. The system maintains consistent levels of CO2, temperature, and dissolved oxygen (DO) over multi-month experiments without automated control units, relying instead on robust initial settings. High-purity CO2 and N2 gases are blended with ambient air in controlled ratios to regulate carbonate chemistry and oxygen levels, while chillers and heaters ensure precise temperature control. Validation experiments demonstrated that the system can (1) increase pCO2 to approximately twice the present-day level with a pH reduction of ~ 0.22 units, (2) elevate temperature by + 3 °C above ambient temperature, and (3) reduce DO by up to 40% relative to ambient concentration, reflecting projected climate scenarios. This simple and versatile mesocosm provides a practical platform for investigating the ecophysiological responses of marine organisms under multi-stressor environments, supporting research on climate adaptation and aquaculture resilience.
Continue reading ‘An indoor mesocosm system for cost-effective simulation of multiple ocean stressors affecting marine organisms’Posts Tagged 'oxygen'
An indoor mesocosm system for cost-effective simulation of multiple ocean stressors affecting marine organisms
Published 16 January 2026 Science Leave a CommentTags: laboratory, methods, multiple factors, oxygen, temperature
Strength and duration of diel pH and dissolved oxygen cycles control the survival and performance of early life stage North Atlantic bivalves (Mercenaria mercenaria, Crassostrea virginica, Argopecten irradians and Mytilus edulis)
Published 9 January 2026 Science Leave a CommentTags: biological response, growth, laboratory, mollusks, mortality, multiple factors, North Atlantic, oxygen, physiology, reproduction, respiration
Highlights
- Cycling from nocturnal hypoxia – acidification to mild hyperoxia- hypocapnia reduced larval survival in all experiments.
- Cycling from nocturnal hypoxia – acidification to normoxia- normocapnia reduced survival of larvae in 50 % of experiments.
- Nocturnal hypoxia and acidification caused increased clearance and respiration rates in juvenile mussels.
- The impacts of diel DO and pH cycles on early life stage bivalves depend on cycle duration, cycle intensity, and species.
Abstract
Many economically important bivalves spawn during the summer months when diel cycles of dissolved oxygen (DO) and pH occur in estuaries. Little is known, however, regarding how cycles of differing durations and magnitudes affect these organisms. Here, larval bivalves (Mercenaria mercenaria, Crassostrea virginica, Argopecten irradians) and juvenile mussels (Mytilus edulis) were exposed to cycles of low DO and pH of varying duration (4-, 6-, 8-, and 12-h) and strength (moderate: DO range ∼ 6 mg L−1, pH range ∼ 0.6 and severe: DO range ∼ 10 mg L−1, pH range ∼ 0.9) compared to positive (normoxic and normocapnic) and negative (hypoxic and acidified) static controls. Growth, survival, respiration and clearance rates were measured. During experiments, 12 h of nocturnal hypoxia and acidification coupled with mildly hyperoxic (∼11.3 mg L−1 DO) and hypocapnic (∼8.13 pH) conditions by day significantly reduced survival in larval C. virginica, M. mercenaria, and A. irradians in all experiments (p < 0.05), while 12 h of nocturnal hypoxia and acidification without hyperoxic and hypocapnic conditions did so in only half of experiments indicating that hyperoxia and hypocapnia were additional and significant stressors. Six hours of low DO/pH significantly reduced survival in only 16 % of experiments, indicating that larval bivalves are more impacted by longer duration and greater magnitude cycles of DO and pH compared to cycles of shorter duration or lower magnitude. Across species, M. mercenaria larvae were more resilient to nocturnal hypoxia and acidification than A. irradians and C. virginica. The growth and survival of juvenile M. edulis were unaffected by nocturnal hypoxia and acidification but mussels experienced significantly increased clearance and respiration rates under these conditions (p < 0.01) evidencing physiological mechanisms for coping with these stressors. Collectively, this study demonstrates that the impacts of diel DO and pH cycles on early life stage bivalves are dependent upon cycle duration, cycle intensity, bivalve life stage, and bivalve species.
Continue reading ‘Strength and duration of diel pH and dissolved oxygen cycles control the survival and performance of early life stage North Atlantic bivalves (Mercenaria mercenaria, Crassostrea virginica, Argopecten irradians and Mytilus edulis)’Effect of experimental seawater acidification on the prooxidant-antioxidant system of the Pacific oyster Magallana gigas (Thunberg, 1793) under normoxic and hypoxic conditions
Published 8 January 2026 Science Leave a CommentTags: biological response, Black Sea, fisheries, laboratory, mollusks, mortality, multiple factors, oxygen, physiology
Highlights
- Lipid peroxidation in oyster gills was enhanced during exposure to acidification + hypoxia.
- SOD and GPx activities changed in gills and hepatopancreas, while CAT activity unchanged in both.
- Water acidification does not promote DNA strand breaks in hemocytes of M. gigas.
- Acidification + hypoxia more severe damaging than acidification under normoxia.
Abstract
Bivalve mollusks, particularly the Pacific oyster (Magallana gigas), are both environmentally and commercially significant species that live in coastal waters and may be affected by global climate change factors including hypoxia and acidification. In this study, we investigated the impact of acidification in combination with normoxia and hypoxia on oxidative stress markers in the gills and hepatopancreas of M. gigas oysters. Oysters were collected from a shellfish farm and subjected to acidified conditions (pH 7.3 ± 0.05) in combination with either normoxic (8.0 ± 0.3 mg/L O2) or hypoxic (2.0 ± 0.3 mg/L O2) conditions for an 8-day period. Changes of DNA damage levels, reactive oxygen species (ROS) production in hemocytes, as well as antioxidant enzyme activities (catalase (CAT), superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione peroxidase (GPx)) and lipid peroxidation in the gills and hepatopancreas were evaluated. Additionally, the mortality rate in experimental groups was monitored throughout the experiment. Our results showed that lipid peroxidation in gills was enhanced during prolonged acidification in combination with hypoxia (6–8 days). We observed rapid and consistent changes in SOD and GPx activity in gills and hepatopancreas. CAT activity remained stable in both tissues. The results of the study indicate that acidification was shown to induce oxidative stress in oysters. Combination of acidic environment to hypoxia had a more severe effect on oysters compared to acidification under normal oxygen conditions, leading to their death after 8 days of exposure.
Continue reading ‘Effect of experimental seawater acidification on the prooxidant-antioxidant system of the Pacific oyster Magallana gigas (Thunberg, 1793) under normoxic and hypoxic conditions’Compound hypoxia with heat or acidification stress induces synergistic and additive effects on coral physiology
Published 26 December 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, BRcommunity, corals, laboratory, morphology, multiple factors, North Atlantic, oxygen, photosynthesis, physiology, phytoplankton, respiration
As climate change accelerates, coastal marine ecosystems are increasingly exposed to co-occurring stressors whose combined effects are nonlinear and difficult to predict. Deoxygenation is a rapidly intensifying yet underrecognized threat to coral reefs that interacts with heat and acidification to alter coral physiology and stress resilience. However, the effects of hypoxia-related compound events on corals are largely unknown, underscoring the need for multi-stressor studies. Here, we conducted two extended-exposure experiments (12–17 days) across the coral species Porites furcata, Porites astreoides and Siderastrea siderea, to disentangle the individual and combined effects of low dissolved oxygen (hypoxia) with either heat or acidification. We measured eight phenotypic traits related to growth, metabolism, and symbiosis health to test whether hypoxia imposes energetic constraints or other physiological stress that amplify the effects of heat or acidification. Standardized effect size analysis across 24 stressor–trait combinations revealed 13 additive, 10 synergistic, and only one antagonistic response. Hypoxia consistently suppressed dark respiration by 37–49% across species and altered photophysiology in the two Porites species, whereas acidification alone had minimal effects, particularly in S. siderea. Heat stress caused the most pronounced declines across nearly all traits, and when combined with hypoxia, it produced the highest number of synergistic interactions. In contrast, the combination of hypoxia and acidification largely resulted in additive responses, suggesting that independent physiological mechanisms underlie these effects. All corals showed strong metabolic depression under hypoxia which is likely beneficial as a short-term adaptive response but may impose energetic constraints in the long-term. These findings highlight deoxygenation as critical yet often overlooked drivers of coral reef vulnerability. More multi-stressor experiments across a range of species are urgently needed to improve predictions of reef resilience under future ocean conditions, where compound stress events are expected to become more frequent and severe.
Continue reading ‘Compound hypoxia with heat or acidification stress induces synergistic and additive effects on coral physiology’Resistance of the cold-water coral Dendrophyllia cornigera to single and combined global change stressors
Published 28 November 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, corals, growth, laboratory, morphology, mortality, multiple factors, North Atlantic, oxygen, respiration, temperature
Current knowledge of the consequences on global change in deep marine ecosystems is still limited, especially since environmental pressures do not act separately, and their potential interactions are mostly unknown. Cold-water corals (CWC) play a significant role in the deep sea, being ecosystem engineers supporting high biodiversity. However, global change may impact CWCs, compromising their integrity and survival. In this study, a nine-month aquaria experiment was conducted on the CWC Dendrophyllia cornigera from the NW Iberian Shelf (NE Atlantic Ocean). The aim was to assess the individual and combined effects of elevated temperature (12 vs. 15 °C), low pH (~ 7.99 vs. 7.69 pHT) and low oxygen (~ 6.4 vs. 4.7 mL L−1), based on the IPCC RCP 8.5 scenario. During the experiment, coral survival, skeletal growth, tissue cover and respiration were monitored as response variables. No significant effects were found on any of the response variables for either individual or combined stressors, pointing to the resistance of D. cornigera to different global change scenarios. Such a physiological resistance may support D. cornigera persistence under future conditions where other CWCs with narrower tolerance ranges may face greater limitations. However, further research is needed to assess potential trade-offs to cope with environmental change, which might impact the long-term survival capacity of this species.
Continue reading ‘Resistance of the cold-water coral Dendrophyllia cornigera to single and combined global change stressors’The multiple responses of Mytilus galloprovincialis in the multi-stressor scenario: impacts of low pH, low dissolved oxygen, and microplastics
Published 18 November 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, laboratory, Mediterranean, mollusks, multiple factors, oxygen, physiology, plastics, respiration
Highlights
- Low pH, low dissolved oxygen (DO), and microplastics (MPs) did not notably affect organismal parameters or ETS activity.
- Stressors significantly affected hemocytes, genotoxicity, and gill metabolites individually and interactively.
- Hemolymph phagocytic activity, granulocyte/hyalinocyte ratio, and mantle lipid peroxidation were partly affected.
- Metabolomic analyses showed that mussel gills are valuable indicators of metabolic status under stress.
Abstract
Along with high temperatures, acidification, deoxygenation, and microplastics (MPs) pollution represent key drivers in coastal marine ecosystems. Sessile invertebrates living in coastal habitats are primarily exposed to the combination of these drivers, often at severe levels. Here, we investigated the individual and combined impacts of low pH (pHT: 7.35), low dissolved oxygen (DO) (1.91 mg L−1), and MP (26 μg L−1) in the Mediterranean mussel Mytilus galloprovincialis by measuring organismal and cellular parameters after a 15-day exposure period. Organismal parameters (respiration rate, ammonia excretion rate, absorption efficiency) as well as electron transport system (ETS) activity were not impacted by the stressors, either individually or combined. At the cellular level, however, we observed significant effects of these stressors individually and interactively on the hemocyte count, hemocyte viability, genotoxicity (comet assay), and gill metabolite profiles. In addition, we observed partial effects on the hemolymph phagocytic activity (PA) and granulocyte/hyalinocyte (G/H) ratio, and mantle lipid peroxidation (LPO). Metabolomics results manifested that the gill of mussels can serve as a valuable indicator of metabolic status under the stress of low pH, low DO and MP. Metabolites involved in osmoregulation, membrane stability, oxidative stress, energy, amino acid and nitrogen metabolism were significantly affected by the stressors, with low DO being the main driver of metabolic changes. We suggest that the individual and variable interactions of these stressors negatively impact M. galloprovincialis, except for the organismal and, to some extent, biochemical parameters.
Continue reading ‘The multiple responses of Mytilus galloprovincialis in the multi-stressor scenario: impacts of low pH, low dissolved oxygen, and microplastics’The influence of maternal size/age effects on the physiological responses of adult female gopher rockfish (Sebastes carnatus) to ocean acidification and hypoxia
Published 13 August 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, fish, laboratory, multiple factors, North Pacific, oxygen, physiology, reproduction
Climate change is rapidly reshaping the chemistry of the ocean. Fishes living in California coastal waters are experiencing increased ocean acidification and hypoxia (OAH) due to more frequent and intense upwelling. Nearshore rockfish may be particularly threatened by these conditions due to their long generational times. However, it is unknown how OAH may impact maternal physiology and reproduction in these viviparous fish. To understand the physiological effects of OAH during gestation, adult female gopher rockfish, Sebastes carnatus, were exposed to a variety of combined OAH stress treatments during different gestational stages. Routine metabolic rate (RMR), maximum metabolic rate (MMR), blood hematocrit (Hct), hemoglobin (tHb), pCO2, HCO3–, Na+, K+, Cl–, and metabolites, were measured to assess physiological responses to OAH stress. Ovarian oxygen was measured to examine the ability to buffer embryos against low oxygen. Fish exposed to higher OAH stress displayed elevated blood Hct, tHb, pCO2 and HCO3–, and decreased MMR, indicating attempted compensation for low pH and hypoxia (with varying levels of success), at increased physiological costs. Fish showed signs of buffering their ovaries against hypoxia. Lastly, pregnancy altered Hct and RMR under OAH exposure and size/age did not have a consistent effect on maternal physiology. By evaluating responses of maternal physiology to OAH stress, we can better understand how climate change affects fecundity, larval condition, and survival, influencing nearshore fisheries in an ever-changing climate.
Continue reading ‘The influence of maternal size/age effects on the physiological responses of adult female gopher rockfish (Sebastes carnatus) to ocean acidification and hypoxia’Impacts of multiple coastal stressors across life-history stages in the eastern oyster
Published 31 July 2025 Science ClosedTags: adaptation, biological response, laboratory, molecular biology, mollusks, multiple factors, otherprocess, oxygen, reproduction
Urbanized estuaries are characterized as a complex of biotic and abiotic stressors, which currently challenge marine life and are expected to intensify and become increasingly unpredictable under the ongoing impacts of climate change. The persistence of coastal species that inhabit these stressful environments will ultimately depend on their ability to adapt. Many of these species have complex life cycles, featuring distinct morphological and physiological developmental stages that can exhibit unique responses to environmental pressures. However, since all stages share the same genome, selective pressures acting on one stage can have cascading effects throughout the life cycle. The larval stage, being particularly sensitive to environmental stressors and often the only free-moving stage, plays a crucial role in gene flow across populations. Consequently, selection during this stage can set the trajectory for the entire life cycle and significantly influence the adaptive structure of populations. This dissertation explores the impacts of multiple environmental stressors across the life-history stages of the eastern oyster (Crassostrea virginica). In Chapter 1, we integrated genomic information about larval stressor response into a seascape genomics framework, using adult oysters sampled from various localities with differing environmental profiles in Narragansett Bay, Rhode Island. We identified environmentally driven signatures of local adaptation corresponding to different genomic regions, even amidst high gene flow. In loci putatively under selection in larvae exposed to coastal stressors, we found stressor-specific associations with environmental conditions that aligned with adult candidate loci, highlighting the critical role of the larval stage in shaping population adaptive divergence. In Chapter 2, we exposed genetically diverse pools of larval oysters to diurnal fluctuating acidification and hypoxia for most of their development. Genomic analysis of samples taken before and after exposure revealed substantial shifts in allele frequencies at loci putatively under selection, suggesting a potential for rapid adaptation to future environmental conditions. Chapter 3 extended this work by exposing oysters to these stressors from the pediveliger stage, through settlement, and into early juvenile development. Genomic analysis from the larval and settlement exposure periods revealed both unique and shared signatures of selection across the early developmental stages. While the juvenile stage was more tolerant to the stressor conditions, we found that stressor exposure through the pediveliger larval and settlement stages had short-term carryover effects on juvenile performance. These findings demonstrate the complex connection of evolutionary responses across the full life cycle. While early developmental stages are sensitive to coastal stressors, our analysis reveals adaptive responses that highlight the resilience of this species. Specifically, these early life-stage responses can influence later developmental stages, shaping the species’ overall adaptive capacity and impacting population structure dynamics. Consequently, understanding these dynamics is crucial for predicting how population structure and adaptive divergence will evolve in response to intensifying coastal stressors.
Continue reading ‘Impacts of multiple coastal stressors across life-history stages in the eastern oyster’Metabolic responses of the European flat oyster (Ostrea edulis) to combined ocean acidification and hypoxia
Published 18 July 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, laboratory, Mediterranean, mollusks, multiple factors, oxygen, performance, physiology, respiration
Ocean acidification and the accompanying hypoxia, which have become increasingly important environmental stress factors, can have varying effects on marine organisms, such as impaired physiological metabolism and immune function. Here, I studied the effects of high pCO2 and low dissolved oxygen (DO) in European flat oyster Ostrea edulis. Changes in physiological and immunological parameters were investigated in oysters during 18 days of exposure at two different pH (7.90 and 7.30) and DO levels (7.5 and 2 mg L-1). Low pH and low DO reduced haemocye count and viability, both individually and in combination. Low pH and combined exposure decreased feeding and respiration, which exacerbated by duration. Low pH and low dissolved oxygen increased ammonia excretion rate, which exacerbated by time. I suggest that the low pH and low DO lead metabolic depression, impaired immune function, and alteration in energy allocation in oysters, which further collectively negatively affect fitness of the oyster.
Continue reading ‘Metabolic responses of the European flat oyster (Ostrea edulis) to combined ocean acidification and hypoxia’Cross-generational plasticity in Atlantic silversides (Menidia menidia) under the combined effects of hypoxia and acidification
Published 17 July 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, fish, laboratory, molecular biology, mortality, multiple factors, North Atlantic, oxygen, physiology, reproduction
We investigated the potential for cross-generational plasticity to influence how offspring respond to hypoxia and ocean acidification (hereafter HypOA) in the coastal forage fish Atlantic silverside (Menidia menidia). Mature wild silversides were treated with a control (dissolved oxygen (DO):100% air saturation (a.s.) / pCO2: 650 µatm) or HypOA conditions (DO: 40% a.s. / pCO2: 2300 µatm) for 10 days prior to spawning. Their offspring were reared under both treatments in factorial experimental design. Parental environment had minimal effects on offspring phenotype: exposure to HypOA reduced survival and developmental rates regardless of parental treatment. However, RNAseq analysis revealed that direct offspring exposure to HypOA induced substantial transcriptional changes, with 1,606 differentially expressed transcripts (DETs) in larvae from control parents. These changes affected neural development, synaptic signaling, oxygen acquisition, and extracellular matrix organization. In contrast, larvae from HypOA-exposed parents exhibited a muted transcriptional response to HypOA, with only 4 DETs. Although we did not detect a statistically significant interaction between parental and offspring environments at the gene-wise level, a gene set test supported a consistent attenuation of expression changes in offspring from HypOA-treated parents. This pattern may be consistent with transcriptional frontloading, when stress-induced changes are retained and may modify future responses. However, because this effect did not improve offspring performance under HypOA, they are unlikely to represent an adaptive response. Instead, they may reflect non-adaptive carryover effects of parental exposure. Our findings highlight the potential for cross-generational effects to shape transcriptional plasticity, even in the absence of benefits to offspring.
Continue reading ‘Cross-generational plasticity in Atlantic silversides (Menidia menidia) under the combined effects of hypoxia and acidification’Nutritional status and shell properties of the scallop Argopecten purpuratus are sensitive to intense upwelling events
Published 8 July 2025 Science ClosedTags: adaptation, biological response, field, mollusks, morphology, multiple factors, otherprocess, oxygen, physiology, South Pacific, temperature
Highlights
- The scallop Argopecten purpuratus cope with permanent environmental fluctuations.
- Upwelling intensity and duration affect its physiological perfomance.
- Shell organic matrix was adversely affected by intense upwelling events.
- The nutritional status of the A. purpuratus is modulated by upwelling intensity.
- A. purpuratus seems to be partially adapted to colder, low pH and hypoxic conditions.
Abstract
Changes in environmental conditions can be particularly stressful for marine biota. However, marine organisms possess a variety of biological mechanisms (e.g., expression of stress proteins, down or up metabolic regulation, among others) that enable them to adapt to such conditions. This will ultimately determine their resilience and adaptive capacity to the natural environmental fluctuations occurring in their habitats, but also to future climate-driven shifts. In Chile, the scallop Argopecten purpuratus inhabits regions under permanent upwelling conditions causing, at different temporal and spatial scales, cooling, low pH and hypoxic conditions of diverse magnitude. In one-year field experiment, we observed that A. purpuratus was, in some occasions, adversely affected by intense upwelling events during the spring season, when the most intense upwelling events were observed, and thus the lowest temperatures, pH and oxygen levels were registered. These effects were more evident in some shell properties, such as the shell organic matrix, a key component of the biomineralization process. Also, no impacts or positive responses (i.e., up-regulation) were observed on parameters associated to their nutritional status (i.e., carbohydrate and protein muscle content), and periostracum thickness suggesting the presence of physiological trade-offs, but also adaptive mechanisms serving to cope with stressful environmental conditions. Ultimately, our findings also raise concerns about the potential consequences of intensified upwelling due to climate change, particularly for the aquaculture sector that relies on this species, since the majority of impacts were observed in individuals of sizes considered attractive to the market.
Continue reading ‘Nutritional status and shell properties of the scallop Argopecten purpuratus are sensitive to intense upwelling events’Developmental and transgenerational effects of climate change on inorganic mercury toxicity in a marine copepod
Published 25 June 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, crustaceans, laboratory, molecular biology, multiple factors, North Pacific, oxygen, physiology, reproduction, zooplankton
Highlights
- Offspring/persistent OA plus OW aggravated IHg toxicity in T. japonicus.
- Persistent OA had stronger mitigating effect on IHg toxicity than offspring OA.
- OA plus OW intensified IHg toxicity in copepods mainly via lysosome dysfunction.
- Persistent OA enhanced energy metabolism and Hg efflux, decreasing IHg toxicity.
- Different scenarios of climate change can variably affect IHg toxicity in copepods.
Abstract
Dynamic shifts in multiple stressors are frequent in the marine environment. Here, we conducted a multigenerational experiment (F1-F4) to explore how different temporal scenarios of climate change, i.e., offspring/persistent ocean acidification (OA), warming (OW), and their combination (AW), could affect inorganic mercury (IHg) toxicity in the marine copepod Tigriopus japonicus. We found that persistent OA exhibited stronger mitigating effect on IHg toxicity in copepods than offspring OA, while offspring/persistent OW and AW aggravated its toxicity effects. We specifically performed transcriptomic analysis for the copepods of F4. Our transcriptomic result showed energy metabolism and detoxification were activated by persistent OA, enabling the copepods to resist IHg exposure. Instead, detoxification- and reproduction-related processes were inhibited in IHg-treated copepods under offspring/persistent OW and AW scenarios. Although apoptosis was suppressed to probably protect IHg-treated copepods under persistent AW, oxidative stress and lysosomal dysfunction ultimately caused reproductive impairment. Our study highlights that offspring/persistent (i.e., developmental/transgenerational) OA and OW could differentially modulate Hg toxicity in marine copepods, and more studies should focus on the temporal variation and complex interaction of multiple stressors, helping accurately project marine biota’s response in the future ocean.
Continue reading ‘Developmental and transgenerational effects of climate change on inorganic mercury toxicity in a marine copepod’Multiple-stressor effects of ocean warming, acidification and hypoxia on the locomotor behavior of sea cucumber Apostichopus japonicus
Published 6 March 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, echinoderms, laboratory, multiple factors, North Pacific, oxygen, performance, temperature
Highlights
- Ocean warming, acidification, and hypoxia simultaneously affect marine organisms.
- The combined stress significantly affects the locomotor behavior of A. japonicus.
- The movement intensity of A. japonicus was increased under combined stressors.
- The erratic movement patterns indicates a stress-induced escape response.
Abstract
Driven by human activities, global climate change is causing unprecedented changes in marine ecosystems, such as ocean warming, ocean acidification and hypoxia. These stressors, which often occur simultaneously and interact with each other, have significant negative impacts on marine organisms and ecosystems, and are referred to as the “deadly trio”. Understanding how these environmental stressors affect marine organisms is critical, particularly concerning their behavior and survival. Locomotion behavior, an essential aspect of an organism’s ability to find food, evade predators, and reproduce, can be significantly disrupted by environmental changes. The sea cucumber (Apostichopus japonicus), an IUCN-listed endangered species further threatened by climate change, serves as a crucial model organism for studying these effects. This study investigates the impact of combined stressors—ocean warming, acidification and hypoxia on the locomotion behavior of A. japonicus under future ocean scenarios. Cumulative movement distance, cumulative movement time, mean velocity, and maximum velocity of sea cucumbers were measured. The results show that the synergetic interaction of environmental stressors alters locomotor behavior of A. japonicus, increasing movement activity with more erratic patterns. Specifically, compared to the control group (NC), the combined stress group (WAH) showed an increase in cumulative movement time from 79.06 % to 93.40 % (P < 0.05), an increase in cumulative movement distance from 2722.11 cm to 5700.09 cm (P < 0.01), and an increase in mean velocity from 4.63 cm/s to 9.50 cm/s (P < 0.05). These findings indicate that combined stressors significantly affect the locomotion behavior of A. japonicus, providing new insights into its behavioral phenotypic adjustments or responses to environmental stress. This study emphasizes the importance of understanding the impacts of multiple-factor stressors on marine organisms to better predict and mitigate the effects of global climate change.
Continue reading ‘Multiple-stressor effects of ocean warming, acidification and hypoxia on the locomotor behavior of sea cucumber Apostichopus japonicus’Assessing benthic invertebrate vulnerability to ocean acidification and de-oxygenation in California: the importance of effective oceanographic monitoring networks
Published 21 February 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, chemistry, crustaceans, echinoderms, fisheries, methods, multiple factors, oxygen, policy, review
Greenhouse gas emissions from land-use change, fossil fuel, agriculture, transportation, and electricity sectors expose marine ecosystems to overlapping environmental stressors. Existing climate vulnerability assessment methods analyze the frequency of extreme conditions but often minimally consider how environmental data gaps hinder assessments. Here, we show an approach that assesses vulnerability and the uncertainty introduced by monitoring data gaps, using a case study of ocean acidification and deoxygenation in coastal California. We employ 5 million publicly available oceanographic observations and existing studies on species responses to low pH, low oxygen conditions to calculate vulnerability for six ecologically and economically valuable benthic invertebrate species: red sea urchin (Mesocentrotus franciscanus), purple sea urchin (Strongylocentrotus purpurpatus), warty sea cucumber (Apostichopus parvimensis), pink shrimp (Pandalus jordani), California spiny lobster (Panulirus interruptus), and Dungeness crab (Metacarncinus magister). Further, we evaluate the efficacy of current monitoring programs by examining how data gaps heighten associated uncertainty. We find that most organisms experience low oxygen (<35% saturation) conditions less frequently than low pH ( < 7.6) conditions. It is only deeper dwelling (>75 m depth) life stages such as Dungeness crab adults and pink shrimp embryos, juveniles, and adults that experience more frequent exposure to low oxygen conditions. Adult Dungeness crabs experience the strongest seasonal variation in exposure. Though these trends are intriguing, exposure remains low for most species despite well-documented pH and oxygen declines and strengthening upwelling in the central portions of the California Current. Seasonal biases of data collection and sparse observations near the benthos and at depths where organisms most frequently experience stressful conditions undermine exposure estimates. Herein we provide concrete examples of how pink shrimp and Dungeness crab fisheries may be impacted by our findings, and provide suggestions for incorporating oceanographic data into management plans. By limiting our scope to California waters and assessing the limitations presented by current monitoring coverage, this study aims to provide a granular, actionable framework that policymakers and managers can build from to prioritize targeted enhancements and sustained funding of oceanographic monitoring recommendations.
Continue reading ‘Assessing benthic invertebrate vulnerability to ocean acidification and de-oxygenation in California: the importance of effective oceanographic monitoring networks’The combined effects of ocean acidification and hypoxia, part 1
Published 5 February 2025 Presentations , Resources ClosedTags: chemistry, mitigation, multiple factors, oxygen
Dr. Richard Feely (NOAA/PMEL) presents on “The Combined Effects of Ocean Acidification and Hypoxia” (Part 1) with Dr. Nina Bednarsek (Oregon State University) at our December 5th, 2024 Partnerships for Tribal Carbon Solutions workshop: Can Rocks Fix the Climate and Heal the Sea? Richard Feely from NOAA’s Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory discusses ocean acidification in the Pacific Northwest, one of the most vulnerable regions globally. He explains how rising atmospheric CO₂ leads to ocean acidification through chemical reactions that increase hydrogen ion concentration, lowering pH and reducing carbonate availability, which threatens calcifying marine organisms. He highlights how coastal upwelling and biological respiration amplify acidification, making subsurface waters particularly susceptible. Using models and observational data, he demonstrates that acidification is progressing rapidly, with pH declines exceeding EPA water quality criteria in some areas. He emphasizes that adding ocean alkalinity could counteract these changes, offering a potential strategy to mitigate acidification’s impacts.
Global Ocean Health, 29 January 2025. Video.
Investigating the effects of environmental stress on coastal zooplankton populations: from mechanistic drivers to trophic impacts
Published 29 January 2025 Science ClosedTags: abundance, biological response, BRcommunity, crustaceans, field, laboratory, mortality, multiple factors, otherprocess, oxygen, performance, zooplankton
Environmental stressors, such as hypoxia and acidification, are increasing in intensity, duration, and extent in coastal waters and estuaries. Environmental stressors are known to affect a wide range of marine species, including zooplankton. Zooplankton are a critical link in marine food webs, connecting phytoplankton to higher trophic levels such as economically important fish, and are thought to be informative indicators of ecosystem change. For this reason, increased attention has been paid to understanding the mechanisms shaping zooplankton populations. Previous studies have shown that zooplankton exhibit both lethal and sublethal responses to changes in dissolved oxygen and pH. However, there is a range of species-specific responses to stressors. Different responses across species alter zooplankton community composition and spatial distributions, directly impacting predator-prey interactions and the trophic dynamics in coastal environments. This dissertation integrates laboratory experiments, in situ observations, and field work to understand how environmental stressors affect coastal zooplankton populations and nearshore food webs. In Chapter 1, I conducted laboratory experiments to investigate whether the copepod, Calanus pacificus, showed behavioral responses to stressors, and whether these responses lead to changes in vertical population distributions. Our laboratory experiments demonstrated significant effects of bottom water hypoxia and acidification on behavioral avoidance, swimming statistics, and apparent mortality rates in C. pacificus. In Chapter 2, I used a remote camera system to quantify in situ behavioral responses of zooplankton to stressors, using results from Chapter 1 to generate hypotheses about observations in the field. Our in situ videos revealed that copepods in stressful conditions exhibited significantly slower swimming speeds than copepods in non-stressful conditions, while amphipods showed significantly decreased abundances within stressful conditions. Finally, in Chapter 3, I collected zooplankton net tows in an intertidal estuary to investigate the transport of pelagic species into eelgrass beds and the role of eelgrass beds as potential sinks of pelagic zooplankton over the tidal cycle, potentially due to predation by juvenile fish. We found evidence of transport of pelagic species into intertidal habitats and measured large spatial and temporal variability, highlighting the need for sampling programs that can capture small-scale variability. This dissertation provides insight into the mechanisms that link the effects of environmental stressors across individual responses to population, community, and ecosystem level scales and suggests novel methodologies to help advance our understanding of changing zooplankton dynamics.
Continue reading ‘Investigating the effects of environmental stress on coastal zooplankton populations: from mechanistic drivers to trophic impacts’Single-larva RNA sequencing reveals that red sea urchin larvae are vulnerable to co-occurring ocean acidification and hypoxia
Published 22 January 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, dissolution, echinoderms, fisheries, molecular biology, multiple factors, North Pacific, oxygen, physiology, reproduction
Anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions have been increasing rapidly in recent years, driving pH and oxygen levels to record low concentrations in the oceans. Eastern boundary upwelling systems such as the California Current System (CCS) experience exacerbated ocean acidification and hypoxia (OAH) due to the physical and chemical properties of the transported deeper waters. Research efforts have significantly increased in recent years to investigate the deleterious effects of climate change on marine species, but have not focused on the impacts of simultaneous OAH stressor exposure. Additionally, few studies have explored the physiological impacts of these environmental stressors on the earliest life stages, which are more vulnerable and represent natural population bottlenecks in organismal life cycles. The physiological response of the ecologically and commercially important red sea urchin (Mesocentrotus franciscanus) was assessed by exposing larvae to a variety of OAH conditions, mimicking the range of ecologically relevant conditions encountered currently and in the near future along the CCS. Skeleton dissolution, larval development, and gene expression show a response with clearly delineated thresholds that were related to OAH severity. Skeletal dissolution and the induction of Acid-sensing Ion Channel 1A at pH 7.94/5.70 DO mg/L provide particularly sensitive markers of OAH, with dramatic shifts in larval morphology and gene expression detected at the pH/DO transition of 7.71/3.71–7.27/2.72 mg/L. Experimental simulations that describe physiological thresholds and establish molecular markers of OAH exposure will provide fishery management with the tools to predict patterns of larval recruitment and forecast population dynamics.
Continue reading ‘Single-larva RNA sequencing reveals that red sea urchin larvae are vulnerable to co-occurring ocean acidification and hypoxia’An aquaria set-up for long-term, multiple-stressor research in marine organisms
Published 17 January 2025 Science ClosedTags: biological response, laboratory, methods, multiple factors, oxygen, temperature
- Multiple stressor research in aquaria is a useful approach to better understand the ecophysiology of marine species under different environmental conditions, including global change scenarios. Long-term experiments are helpful to detect the response of sustained exposure to selected environmental conditions. Here, we present an experimental set-up suitable to run long-term experiments, composed of a life support system, a cost-effective aquaria set-up and an open-source controller based on the use of a Raspberry Pi. In this set-up, temperature, pH and dissolved oxygen (DO) are individually manipulated and simultaneously controlled in eight different treatments.
- To prove the efficacy of the set-up, we provide an assessment over a nine-month experiment on a deep-sea coral species, combining values from current in situ and IPCC AR5 RCP 8.5 scenarios for the aforementioned parameters. Recorded data from the controllers and independent measurements (e.g. cross-checking with portable multiparameter devices and laboratory analyses) throughout the experimental time have been analysed and results have been discussed.
- Overall, the experimental set-up performed well, proving the stability of the parameters over time, both individually and in combination. On average, low and high-temperature treatments varied ~0.4 and 0.3°C, respectively. Low pH treatments were maintained within 0.05 pH units, whereas ambient pH treatments varied ~0.04 pH units. Low DO treatments had a variation of ~0.3 mg L−1, and ambient DO treatments varied ~0.2 mg L−1. No significant differences between scenarios for any parameter were detected (p < 0.05). The resulting programming code to read, control and register the values for these parameters is provided to contribute to its replicability across institutions.
- The set-up performed well over extensive periods while providing a customisable controller as a cost-effective alternative. The versatility of the system, allowing to work with different species, environments and scenarios makes it valuable for aquaria experiments where interactions of multiple environmental factors need to be tested.
Climate covariate choice and uncertainty in projecting species range shifts: a case study in the Eastern Bering Sea
Published 26 December 2024 Science ClosedTags: Arctic, biological response, crustaceans, field, fish, fisheries, modeling, multiple factors, oxygen, regionalmodeling, temperature
Species distribution models (SDMs) are critical to the adaptive management of fisheries under climate change. While many approaches projecting marine species range shifts have incorporated the effects of temperature on movement, there is a need to incorporate a wider suite of ecologically relevant predictors as temperature-based SDMs can considerably under- or over-estimate the rate of species responses to climate shocks. As a subarctic ecosystem at the sea ice margin, the Eastern Bering Sea (EBS) is warming faster than much of the global ocean, resulting in the rapid redistribution of key fishery and subsistence resources. To support long-term planning and adaptation, we combine 40 years of scientific surveys with a high-resolution oceanographic model to examine the effects of bottom temperature, oxygen, pH and a regional climate index (the extent of the EBS ‘cold pool’) on range projections through the end of the century. We use multimodel inference to partition uncertainty among earth systems models, climate scenarios and distribution model parameterizations for several ecologically and economically important EBS groundfish and crabs. Covariate choice is the primary source of uncertainty for most species, with models that account for spatial responses to the cold pool performing better and suggesting more extensive northward movements than alternative models. Models suggest declines in the probability of occurrence at low pH and oxygen concentrations for most species. We project shifts that are directionally consistent with, yet larger than those previously estimated for most species, suggesting that accounting for large-scale climate variability in species distribution models may substantially alter range projections.
Continue reading ‘Climate covariate choice and uncertainty in projecting species range shifts: a case study in the Eastern Bering Sea’Energy budget as a tool to assess the effects of environmental stressors: a study on whiteleg shrimp (Penaeus vannamei) exposed to variations in salinity and ocean acidification
Published 10 October 2024 Science ClosedTags: biological response, crustaceans, growth, laboratory, multiple factors, oxygen, physiology, salinity, temperature
Our goal was to use the energy budget as a tool to evaluate the effects of salinity (20, 25, 30, 35 or 40‰) and ocean acidification (pH 8.0 or 7.3) in Penaeus vannamei. We assessed the energy budget a range of physiological processes (ingestion, defecation, growth, metabolism, excretion, energy substrate, hepatosomatic index, and osmoregulation). In general, salinity had an accentuated effect than pH, as it altered nearly all physiological parameters, including the energy channeled into growth (up to −56%). Reduced pH also affected the energy budget: increased energy lost in feces (25 and 40‰: +21% and 13%, respectively), excretion (25‰: +55%), and metabolism (20‰: +58%). Furthermore, acidified pH increased oxygen consumption by 60%, which may be related to higher energy expenditure. In conclusion, the energy budget can be a valuable tool for assessing the impacts of environmental stressors and the salinity has an accentuated effect than the ocean acidification predicted.
Continue reading ‘Energy budget as a tool to assess the effects of environmental stressors: a study on whiteleg shrimp (Penaeus vannamei) exposed to variations in salinity and ocean acidification’
